Australia - 3 dead after eating wild mushrooms, Leongatha, Victoria, Aug 2023 #8 *Arrest*

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #621
Last edited:
  • #622
I agree. That would have been smarter.

I'm confused myself about this ----it does sound compulsive and obsessive---but impulsive? I'm not sure because it is also very pre-meditated and organised with long term preplanning.

She allegedly, possibly, drove to a sighting of Death Caps and foraged. And bought the dehydrator back then as well. Then made the toxic mushroom powder and stashed it away until needed?

So obsessive, compulsive, sinister but also pre-meditated and organised. But wildly stupid and ill advised.
I'm thinking an impulse in this instance could be like an urge - not necessarily a quick act, but a feeling that eats away at you. Something like a smoker who's given up. They have the urge to smoke, but don't always act on it right away, they fight it until they give in at a point in the future. Perhaps she had the feeling eating away at her until she chose to act?
MOO
 
  • #623



Live

Toxicologist Mark Douglas who identified the guests at Erin Patterson's house had been poisoned to give evidence​

A toxicologist who the court has heard suggest the four lunch guests who dined at Erin Patterson's house had been poisoned by death cap mushrooms is due to give evidence on Wednesday morning.

Ellie Dudley

@EllieDudley_


May 7, 2025 - 9:22AM
 
  • #624

Key Event
11m ago

Welcome to today's blog​

By Tim Callanan​

We're expecting more witnesses to face questions from the prosecution and defence in court today.

Again, court reporter Kristian Silva will provide updates from inside the courtroom at the Latrobe Valley Law Courts in Morwell.

1m ago

Ian Wilkinson back at the trial venue​


By Tim Callanan​

Yesterday, we heard testimony from Ian Wilkinson, who is the only lunch guest to survive after consuming poisonous mushrooms in the beef Wellington.

It's not yet clear who will take the witness stand today, but Mr Wilkinson was spotted arriving at the Latrobe Valley Law Courts earlier this morning.

lcimg-5abd3262-7565-4e80-8328-3c993c76663f.jpeg
Ian Wilkinson walks into the court at Morwell. (ABC News)
Now that he's given evidence, Mr Wilkinson would be free to watch the trial in court like other members of the public.
 
Last edited:
  • #625
Key Event
3m ago

Hello from inside Courtroom 4​




By Kristian Silva​

Hello from inside Courtroom 4 for another day of the Erin Patterson trial.

The Patterson/Wilkinson families have turned up in force today, occupying an entire row of seats on one side of the courtroom. Ian Wilkinson has returned to watch proceedings.

The jury has been brought in, and per the court etiquette, Erin Patterson stands in the court dock as they enter. Today she's wearing a pink linen shirt.

Justice Beale brings up something from yesterday — a medical glossary that was being provided to the jury. He says it's going to be withdrawn from evidence and added back into the case later.

The first witness is Dr Mark Douglas.

 
  • #626

1m ago10.51 AEST
The jurors have entered the court room.

The next witness is Dr Mark Douglas, an emergency medicine registrar at Monash Health. He is giving evidence via video link.

In July 2023, he was working at Dandenong Hospital’s toxicology department as a registrar.
 
  • #627
Key Event
1m ago

Toxicology doctor first up in the witness stand​


By Tim Callanan​

The prosecution has called doctor Mark Douglas to give evidence and he's appearing via video link.

Dr Douglas is an emergency registrar at Monash Health and he's being questioned by prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC.

He explains that he offers management plans for patients who have suffered poisoning.

Dr Douglas was the on-call toxicology expert on July 30, 2023 and was asked for advice that day about Donald Patterson when he was admitted to hospital.

 
  • #628

10.41am

Mushroom lunch guest Ian Wilkinson arrives in court​

Pastor Ian Wilkinson has arrived at court again today, sitting in the body of the court with family ahead of today’s evidence.

Erin Patterson is sitting on the dock wearing a pink shirt.

Ian Wilkinson arrives at court with family members.

Ian Wilkinson arrives at court with family members.Credit: Jason South
 
  • #629
3m ago

Doctor recalls giving advice about ill guests​


By Tim Callanan​

Dr Douglas is explaining some of the tests that were carried out on Don Patterson, including blood tests for liver function.

He says it was explained to him that Mr Patterson had eaten a meal about 12 hour prior that could be the source of his illness.

Dr Douglas says he also understood that day that Mr Patterson's wife Gail had also been admitted to hospital with similar symptoms, as well as two other family members at a different hospital.

 
  • #630
now11.01 AEST
At about 11.30am on 30 July - the day after the fateful mushroom lunch - Douglas received a call from Dr Beth Morgan asking for toxicology advice about a patient – Don Patterson, the court hears.

What I was told was that Don was quite unwell, both in his clinical state and lab state... Gail was not as unwell as Don.
Douglas says he was told two other relatives had similar symptoms to Don and Gail Patterson – the accused, Erin Patterson’s, in-laws.

He says his colleague, a qualified toxicologist, advised that Don could be administered N-acetyl cysteine (NAC) - a medication for liver function.

 
  • #631
Key Event
2m ago

Poisonous mushroom antidote not initially given​

By Tim Callanan​

Dr Douglas says it wasn't initially clear that the illness of the guests was caused by amanita mushrooms, so the specific antidote for that type of mushroom was not administered.

He says liver function and blood test results for Gail Patterson showed her condition was deteriorating and she should be closely monitored.

He made the same assessment for Donald Patterson.

He suggested the antidote should be administered as soon as possible.

1m ago

Doctor treats guests at hospital ICU​


By Tim Callanan​

Dr Douglas says he reviewed Donald Patterson in the ICU at Dandenong Hospital.

He says someone from the ICU nursing team told him the mushrooms which caused the poisoning were purchased from a Woolworths or Asian grocery.

Dr Douglas advised the ICU team to start treament for amanita poisoning and that treatment could be adjusted if information about the source of the poisoning changes.

He also saw Gail Patterson and spoke to her about her husband's status and treatment.

He confirms Gail was later admitted to the ICU.

 
  • #632
4m ago

A brief chat with Donald Patterson in hospital​


By Mikaela Ortolan​

Dr Douglas says he briefly spoke with Don while he was in hospital.

"I can't remember the exact words that were exchanged but he did say he was feeling quite unwell," he says.

He says Don also confirmed that he had eaten a meal of beef Wellington roughly about noon and started to feel unwell around midnight.


1m ago

Doctor discharged after giving evidence​


By Tim Callanan​

Dr Douglas says he saw Ian Wilkinson and his wife Heather at Dandenong Hospital and spoke them about how much of the beef Wellington meal they ate.

That concludes Dr Douglas' evidence.

The defence does not put forward any questions.

 
  • #633
now11.14 AEST

Doctor ordered death cap mushroom antidote two days after lunch, court hears​

By 6.30am the following day – 31st July – Morgan advised Douglas that Don’s condition had worsened and Gail was showing “similar progress”.

Douglas, who was on call, advised Morgan to immediately administer silibinin - the antidote to death cap mushroom poisoning.

Arriving at Dandenong Hospital, Douglas says he reviewed Don in the intensive care unit.

Under questioning by Nanette Rogers SC, the prosecutor, Douglas confirms he was conscious at this point.

Douglas recalls a conversation with medical staff who said the mushrooms in the beef Wellington meal consumed by Don were from an Asian grocer.

Don was then sedated to allow for incubation so he could be transferred to the Austin Hospital which has a major toxicology unit, Douglas says.

Gail was later also transferred to the Austin Hospital, the court he

 
  • #634
6 minutes ago

'Abnormalities' detected in lunch guest's liver​

Dr Mark Douglas is giving evidence.
Dr Douglas is an emergency registrar at Monash Health who was doing a rotation with the toxicology unit, based at Dandenong Hospital when Don and Gail Patterson were admitted there.
He told the court blood tests done at Leongatha and Dandenong hospitals detected “abnormalities” in Don’s liver tests and blood gas tests and that his liver was “quite inflamed”.
He said Don was far sicker than Gail.
“Donald was quite unwell both in his clinical state and lab tests, whereas Gail was symptomatic but wasn’t as unwell as Donald,” Dr Douglas said.
Dr Douglas was told by another treating doctor that Don and several members of his family had eaten a meal about 12 hours prior to the onset of their symptoms.
He said when speaking to Gail, she told him she had only eaten about a third of her meal.
Dr Douglas said Don told him he had eaten a full share of his portion.
Yesterday, the sole survivor of the lunch, Ian Wilkinson, told the court Gail only ate about half her meal, with Don finishing his entire portion and the rest of Gail’s.




2 minutes ago

Initially not enough evidence to suggest death cap consumption: Doctor​

Dr Douglas said he looked at Don’s vital signs and blood tests, before speaking with his lead toxicologist, who said there was not enough evidence to suggest they had consumed death cap mushrooms.
Dr Douglas told the jury Don was administered with N-acetylcysteine (NAC) to protect his liver, but not the antidote to death cap mushroom poisoning, silibinin.
He said the doctors believed several “potential poisons” could have caused their symptoms, but as their conditions continued to worsen, the decision was made to administer silibinin.
“The feeling was that we start the treatment for amanita phalloides (death cap mushrooms),” he said.

1 minutes ago

'Delicious and beautiful': Guest raved about beef wellington before falling ill​

Crown prosecutor Sarah Lenthall is reading out statements from several witnesses to the jury.
Angela Child, the treasurer of the Korumburra Baptist Church, said she saw Heather and Ian, the pastor of the church, after the lunch at Erin’s home.
Ms Child said Heather described the beef wellington meal as “delicious and beautiful”.
“She continued to rave about the meal,” she said.
“Neither Ian or Heather looked sick.”

 
  • #635
Just now

Statements are being read to the court​


By Tim Callanan​

The prosecution is now reading statements from several witnesses who are not in court.

We'll bring you the details of those statements shortly.

 
  • #636
now21.25 EDT
Ian WilkinsonSimon Patterson’s uncle, and a guest at the lunch his estranged wife Erin hosted – was transferred to Dandenong hospital, the court hears.

Dr Mark Douglas says Ian reported experiencing severe nausea and constant vomiting and told staff he had eaten the full portion of the beef wellington lunch.

Ian was also admitted to ICU and then transferred to the Austin Hospital.

Douglas recalls Heather Wilkinson, Ian’s wife, arriving at Dandenong hospital before she was also admitted to ICU and transferred to the Austin:

I do recall her saying it was a delicious meal.
Douglas concludes his evidence. There is no cross-examination.

 
  • #637
11.25am

Emergency toxicologist detected liver abnormalities when patients first adm​

Dr Mark Douglas is an emergency doctor at Monash Health who in 2023 was working as a toxicology registrar.

The jury heard that on the evening of July 30, 2023, Douglas was the on-call toxicologist and provided advice on both Don and Gail Patterson’s treatment during their time at Dandenong Hospital.

Gail and Don Patterson.

Gail and Don Patterson.

About 11.30pm, he got a phone call from Dr Beth Morgan at Dandenong Hospital asking for advice about Don’s condition and treatment, as she was admitting him to her unit from the emergency department.

Douglas said liver and blood tests for Don, whose condition was more serious than Gail’s upon arrival, showed abnormalities.

The jury heard that at the time, doctors were considering whether the lunch could be the cause of the symptoms.

Douglas called the lead toxicologist, who advised him that at this time there was not enough evidence of them having ingested death cap mushrooms. However, they spoke about starting Don on a liver protective medication.

“So at that point the specific antidote wasn’t indicated,” Douglas said.

The jury heard that about 1am on July 31, 2023, Douglas was informed by Gail’s treating doctor that subsequent blood tests had shown that her liver function was worsening. He advised Gail’s treating doctor to start her on some protective liver medication.

Douglas arrived at Dandenong Hospital later that day and examined Don, who was conscious at the time and confirmed that he had consumed a beef Wellington lunch.

“At that stage, I recall that ... we were still unsure about the exact mechanism, and there were several other kind of potential poisons that could have caused such an effect beyond just the mushroom. But the feeling was that we will start the treatment for the Amanita Phalloides [death cap mushrooms] while things are so undecided,” Douglas said.

Shortly after, Don was sedated and prepared for transport to the Austin Hospital.

Douglas said he then assessed Gail in the emergency department. She was awake and told Douglas that Don had eaten part of her meal during the lunch. Gail was later moved to intensive care and eventually taken to the Austin.

The jury heard that Ian and Heather Wilkinson were admitted to Dandenong Hospital, after being transported there from Leongatha, while Douglas was speaking to Gail.

Douglas said Ian reported being extremely nauseous.

“He looked quite ... very nauseated,” he said.

Douglas has concluded his evidence and been excused from the witness box.

 
  • #638
2m ago11.29 AEST

Search found no record of Erin Patterson having received a cancer diagnosis, court hears​

Prosecutor Sarah Lenthall is reading written witness statements to the jury

The first statement is of Angela Child, treasurer of the Korumburra Baptist Church where Ian Wilkinson is the pastor.

She recalls her arriving at Ian and Heather’s house at 3pm on 29 July 2023 – hours after the lethal mushroom lunch.

Heather told her they had a “lovely lunch” and described the beef wellington as “delicious and beautiful”.

“She continued to rave about the meal,” Child says.

She says neither Ian or Heather looked sick.

Danielle Romane, from the state’s department of health, has also made a written statement.

She says a request to search the state’s cancer registry found no record of Erin Patterson having received a cancer diagnosis.

It is mandatory for health services in Victoria to report all cancer diagnosis to the registry, the court hears.

The Korumburra Baptist church in Korumburra, where Ian Wilkinson is the pastor.

The Korumburra Baptist church in Korumburra, where Ian Wilkinson is the pastor. Photograph:James Ross/AAP

 
  • #639
2m ago

Healther Wilkinson raved about the meal, says witness​


By Mikaela Ortolan​

Prosecutor Sarah Lenthall has read out a number of statements from witnesses.

The first statement is from Angela Child who is the treasurer of the Baptist Church Korumburra, where Ian Wilkinson is a pastor.

She says she saw Ian Wilkinson and his wife Heather after the lunch in question.

They had a prearranged meeting at the Wilkinson's home.

She says Ms Wilkinson raved about the meal and said it was delicious.

1m ago

Wilkinson's appeared happy and well after lunch​


By Mikaela Ortolan​

Jennifer McPhee is the director of the Baptist Church Korumburra.

She was also at the prearranged meeting at the Wilkinson's home following the lunch.

She also mentioned that Heather Wilkinson said the meal was delicious and was "playfully teasing Ian about how much he had eaten".

She says when she left the home at around 4pm the couple appeared happy and were not showing signs of sickness, something Angela Childs also said in her statement.

 
  • #640
11.33am

Church members said Heather Wilkinson ‘raved’ about delicious beef Wellington lunch​

The court is now being read a statement from the treasurer of the Korumburra Baptist Church, Angela Child, who is describing the moment she met with Ian and Heather Wilkinson after the lunch at Erin Patterson’s house on July 29, 2023.

She described being outside the Wilkinsons’ home alongside church secretary Jenny McPhee as Ian and Heather arrived from the lunch.

Child said Heather then raved about the lunch.

“She told me that they had beef Wellington and described it as delicious and beautiful. She said it was beef eye fillet. She continued to rave about the meal,” she said.

The jury has also been read a statement from Jenny McPhee, who also described meeting with the couple for about an hour.

“When I left, Ian and Heather were happy and not sick in the slightest,” she said.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
131
Guests online
2,116
Total visitors
2,247

Forum statistics

Threads
632,502
Messages
18,627,698
Members
243,171
Latest member
neckdeepinstories
Back
Top