GUILTY Abby & Libby - The Delphi Murders - Richard Allen Arrested - #220

[dm799]

I'm actually quite surprised the investigators haven't received a lot more flak. Perhaps it's because they all do appear to be geniunely decent people, doing their absolute best.

But we shouldn't forget that this crime was not investigated competently for several years.

All the time wasted on press conferences and appealing for help from outside when everything they needed was under their own roof the entire time.

But they got the break they needed in the end. Not through their own work, but thanks to a volunteer who was able to find the needle they themselves misplaced in their giant investigative haystack.

 

[Justice101]

I'm actually quite surprised the investigators haven't received a lot more flak. Perhaps it's because they all do appear to be geniunely decent people, doing their absolute best.

But we shouldn't forget that this crime was not investigated competently for several years.

All the time wasted on press conferences and appealing for help from outside when everything they needed was under their own roof the entire time.

But they got the break they needed in the end. Not through their own work, but thanks to a volunteer who was able to find the needle they themselves misplaced in their giant investigative haystack.

True.

The case was too big for Delphi and surrounding community. They did get some help from the state and the FBI, but data management ended up being their biggest problem/.

 

[Justice101]

I think they had like 50,000 tips. Had to install a special hotline and database to manage it all... but like you said, the solution was right in their hands all the time

 

[Boxer]

Actually the sad riddle is more like this:

One man was on a bridge.
Two little girls were murdered.
Did the man see the murderer?

How I wish justice hadn't taken all those painful years but I don't want to lose sight of what's easy to forget -- that the tip was found/recognized and that it existed to be found. Had it been discarded and how easily it could have been, he'd still be free...

Slow police work but they got it done.

JMO

Yes. The lady detective from CPS got it done.

 

[Boxer]

I think they had like 50,000 tips. Had to install a special hotline and database to manage it all... but like you said, the solution was right in their hands all the time

MOO RA self report being on the trail was in the first week. They need to take their medicine. They probably lost focus with so much brass descending on the town.

 

[girlhasnoname]

Yes. The lady detective from CPS got it done.

Kathy Shank, a retired CPS worker is the one that came across the folder of cleared tips and zoomed in on RA. She solved the case IMO.

It was human error, but it was a colossal screw up regardless.

 

[Justice101]

Kathy Shank, a retired CPS worker is the one that came across the folder of cleared tips and zoomed in on RA. She solved the case IMO.

It was human error, but it was a colossal screw up regardless.

Unimaginable screw up.

If not for Kathy, the case would likely have never been solved.

 

[Megnut]

Unimaginable screw up.

If not for Kathy, the case would likely have never been solved.

Maybe it's a matter of scale, but the case wouldn't have been solved if Rick hadn't come forward in the first place.

I still credit LE with the initial interview (what's most unfortunate is that the weasel slithered out of an interview AT THE POLICE STATION, where is like to think a seasoned officer would have recognized the stick in Rick's story.

Thankfully there was a record of this early contact. Given where KS found it, it could have met with a paper shredder. That it existed, that it still existed was the only way for KS to find it.

Crazy the accidental mix-up of his name -- street in place of surname -- seems to be what caught KS's eye in the first place.

No question justice was delayed, but in the end, it was not denied.

He's never getting out.

JMO

 

[Vaderman]

Kathy Shank, a retired CPS worker is the one that came across the folder of cleared tips and zoomed in on RA. She solved the case IMO.

It was human error, but it was a colossal screw up regardless.

It's insane just how close he was to completely getting away with it.

 

[Megnut]

It's insane just how close he was to completely getting away with it.

Except....

Apparently a random crime.

A low-population remote setting.

A location without CCTV.

Limited CCTV im the wider area.

No DNA.

An unidentified, bladed murder weapon.

Had Libby not brought CCTV to the bridge (in the form her cellphone camera), there'd be nothing but a sketch... not even a timestamp nor a record as to when, how and from which point they were abducted. Or by whom.

Libby and Abby should get the reward money, for provided the most tips with the greatest clarity. Astounding.

JMO

 

[Justice101]

Except....

Apparently a random crime.

A low-population remote setting.

A location without CCTV.

Limited CCTV im the wider area.

No DNA.

An unidentified, bladed murder weapon.

Had Libby not brought CCTV to the bridge (in the form her cellphone camera), there'd be nothing but a sketch... not even a timestamp nor a record as to when, how and from which point they were abducted. Or by whom.

Libby and Abby should get the reward money, for provided the most tips with the greatest clarity. Astounding.

JMO

Totally agree!

Any one of these below facts would have led to no arrest:

1) No Libby video
2) RA not coming forward.
3) The folder with the cleared person discrepancies not being found/questioned.


That is, the bullet, the eyewitness accounts, and all the other evidence would not been enough to identify or arrest anyone.

 

[Megnut]

Totally agree!

Any one of these below facts would have led to no arrest:

1) No Libby video
2) RA not coming forward.
3) The folder with the cleared person discrepancies not being found/questioned.


That is, the bullet, the eyewitness accounts, and all the other evidence would not been enough to identify or arrest anyone.

And yet, there was video. Courageous joint effort to film their abduction and conceal the phone, even as they were forced to undress, through 18 minutes of what we don't want to imagine, culminating in their vicious murders.

It's too bad that those closest to this sniveling monster didn't have the courage to tip him in. They knew he there that day. They saw the images/clip. Even if they couldn't 100% positively identify him, the coincidence alone should have compelled them to call it in.

Not wanting to believe it's more than a coincidence is not good enough.

JMO

 

[Justice101]

And yet, there was video. Courageous joint effort to film their abduction and conceal the phone, even as they were forced to undress, through 18 minutes of what we don't want to imagine, culminating in their vicious murders.

It's too bad that those closest to this sniveling monster didn't have the courage to tip him in. They knew he there that day. They saw the images/clip. Even if they couldn't 100% positively identify him, the coincidence alone should have compelled them to call it in.

Not wanting to believe it's more than a coincidence is not good enough.

JMO

Agree.

I don't think we are just being Monday morning quarterbacks.